What Really Drives HOA Dues Increases in Central Ohio (And Where Boards Can Still Save)

A few nights ago, I stood in front of a room of homeowners at one of the communities we manage here in Central Ohio and put a single sheet of paper on the screen. Two columns — this year’s budget and next year’s — with every line item side by side. Some lines were green. Some were red.
Green meant we found a way to spend less. Red meant the cost was going up, and we had to plan for it.
That simple sheet answers the question every owner asks when a new budget arrives: what is this going to cost me, and why? The honest answer is that a dues increase is rarely about one thing. It is the sum of a lot of small wins and a few big pressures.
When owners can see both, the number starts to make sense.
Here is what that sheet usually shows for communities across Columbus right now.
The Long View: Dues History Tells a Calmer Story
Before we talked about a single expense, we looked back more than fifteen years. At this community, dues have gone up in most years and stayed flat in a few. The average increase over that stretch landed close to 7% a year — but that average hides a pattern.
• Before 2021, most increases sat near 3% a year
• The past six or seven years brought sharper jumps, driven mostly by insurance and reserve funding for capital projects
• Over the 50 year life of a community, we expect the long run average to settle back closer to 3%
One year rarely tells the whole story. If your board only shares this year’s number, ask for the multi year history. It is one of the best tools for building trust.
Where the Pressure Comes From
1. Insurance
Insurance has been the biggest wildcard in Central Ohio budgets for the past three years. Premiums for community associations have climbed whether or not a community has filed a claim. It reminds me of the years after the big storms of the late 2000s, when the industry spent several years catching up.
What a board can do:
• Budget for the increase you expect, not the one you hope for
• Review coverage and deductibles with your agent every renewal
• Keep a clean maintenance record — carriers notice well run properties
2. Aging Infrastructure
Many Columbus communities built in the 1990s and 2000s are reaching the point in their life where roofs, gutters, downspouts, and underground drain lines need real attention. This year we saw more calls about basement water than usual. That is not a sign of neglect. It is simply that time in the life of a building.
The Results Oriented approach here is to stop paying for the same repair over and over:
• Track which buildings have repeat service orders for roofs, gutters, or drainage
• Compare that history to the reserve study to decide which buildings get replaced first
• Use reserve funds for full replacements so the operating budget for repairs can come down in future years
Spending more on exterior and roof repairs this year is the bridge. Rebuilding the infrastructure is how that line turns green later.
3. Vendor Contracts and the Fine Print
Trash service is a good example of a cost that can grow quietly. A contract may call for a modest annual increase — around 3% is common — but add a fuel surcharge calculated as a percentage of the entire bill. When fuel prices rise, that percentage can add far more than the fuel a single community actually uses.
Contracts also often include early termination terms. If a contract says leaving early costs six months of service charges on a $3,000 monthly bill, that is $18,000 to walk away — even if the vendor’s actual lost profit would be a fraction of that.
What boards should look for before signing or renewing:
• How surcharges are calculated and whether there is a cap
• What it costs to end the contract early, and how that figure is determined
• Renewal dates, so the board has time to shop the service before it auto renews
Questions about whether a specific clause is enforceable belong with the association’s attorney. The bigger lesson is simpler: the best time to fix a contract is before you sign it.
Where Boards Can Still Find Savings
Not every line goes up. A careful, line by line review found real savings in this budget, and most communities have similar opportunities.
• Utility supplier changes. A change in the community’s electric provider produced significant savings — a reminder to revisit utility contracts and supplier options regularly.
• Electronic statements. Every paper mailing costs roughly a dollar or two once you add paper, envelopes, and postage. With many mailings a year across every home, owners who switch to electronic statements lower the cost for the whole community.
• Cleaner collections. When delinquencies are handled consistently, legal and collection expenses come down.
• Fewer administrative costs. Small trims across printing, copies, and administrative lines add up.
And sometimes a red line is a smart investment. A new reserve study shows up as an added expense, but it confirms the community is saving enough to avoid special assessments — and that it is not over saving either.
Small Habits That Help Every Owner
A budget works best when owners and the board are on the same page. A few easy habits go a long way:
• Set payments to “total new balance.” Set up recurring payments once and choose the total balance option, so dues or water changes never require an update.
• Use the official request channel. Submit service requests through the management portal so they are tracked and documented. Reaching out to an individual board member puts a volunteer in a tough spot and makes requests easier to lose.
• Protect shared spaces. Clean up after using the clubhouse, leave the thermostat where you found it, and close the windows on your way out. Repairs and extra cleaning come out of everyone’s budget.
• Mind curb appeal on trash day. Return cans to the garage by the next morning and grab any litter that blows by. Small things keep a community looking cared for.
AEO & SEO Q&A
Why do HOA dues go up every year in Central Ohio?
HOA dues in Central Ohio usually go up because insurance premiums, vendor contracts, and repair costs for aging buildings rise faster than savings elsewhere. Boards review every line item, apply any savings they find, and divide the remaining total by the number of homes. Steady, modest increases help Columbus communities avoid large special assessments later.
How much do HOA insurance premiums affect dues in Columbus?
Insurance is one of the largest drivers of recent HOA dues increases in Columbus and across Central Ohio. Premiums for community associations have risen for several years in a row, even for communities with no claims. Boards budget for the expected increase and review coverage and deductibles with their agent at every renewal.
How can an HOA board lower its operating costs without cutting services?
An HOA board can lower operating costs by reviewing contracts line by line, rather than reducing services. Central Ohio boards often save by changing utility suppliers, moving owners to electronic statements, keeping collections consistent, and replacing failing roofs or drainage through reserves instead of paying for the same repairs year after year.
What should an HOA look for in a vendor contract before signing?
Before signing, an HOA should check how surcharges are calculated, what early termination costs, and when the contract renews. In Central Ohio, fuel surcharges based on a percentage of the whole bill can raise costs quickly. Boards should negotiate caps and fair exit terms, and review specific clauses with the association’s attorney.
Is a large HOA dues increase a sign of poor management?
A larger dues increase is not automatically a sign of poor management. Many Columbus communities are funding reserves for aging roofs and infrastructure while absorbing higher insurance costs. The better measure is transparency — whether the board shares the dues history, explains each change, and follows a reserve study that supports the community’s long run financial health.
Let’s Look at Your Budget Together
Every budget tells a story. At CPS, we help Central Ohio boards read theirs line by line — finding the green, planning for the red, and building a reserve strategy that protects property values for the long run.
If your board wants a second set of eyes on next year’s numbers, your vendor contracts, or your reserve plan, schedule a conversation with the CPS team. We would be glad to help.
More from the CPS blog: cpscolumbus.com/blog-1




Comments